According to the Milan Administrative Court, genuine employment matters when seeking a permit after losing a job
According to the Milan Administrative Court, genuine employment matters when seeking a permit after losing a job
Foreign workers in Italy sometimes find that a permit application becomes complicated because an employment relationship has ended. The question is not simply whether an employer's name appears in an administrative file: the real history of work and the legal conditions for a job-seeking residence permit must be established. In judgment no. 3212 of 16 June 2026, the Regional Administrative Court of Lombardy, Milan, Fourth Section, examined an administrative refusal in light of evidence that a real employment relationship had taken place.
What happened?
The applicant challenged an unfavourable decision concerning the possibility of obtaining a residence permit for awaiting employment, known in Italian as a permesso di soggiorno per attesa occupazione. The dispute centred on whether the underlying employment relationship had actually been established and whether the relevant conditions had been met. The applicant produced documentation showing a genuine work relationship.
The court's reasoning
The court upheld the challenge, finding that the administration's investigation and reasoning had not adequately accounted for the evidence of employment. The existence of a real employment relationship was central to assessing the entitlement to the job-seeking permit in the specific circumstances. Other procedural objections were absorbed by the successful substantive ground.
The judgment should not be read as saying that anyone who arrives in Italy with a work authorisation but is never employed can automatically obtain a job-seeking permit. Under Article 22(11) of Legislative Decree 286/1998, the legal position ordinarily involves the loss of a job after an employment relationship has actually existed. Exceptional circumstances and different procedures require separate legal analysis.
What documents should be kept?
Employment contracts, mandatory hiring notices (UNILAV), payslips, social security records from INPS, termination notices and correspondence with the employer can all help establish what occurred. Where work was seasonal, part-time or interrupted, the exact dates and legal nature of each relationship matter. It is useful to obtain an up-to-date record of employment from the competent services.
If the Questura issues a negative decision, applicants should identify which fact is disputed: the existence of employment, its termination, the applicable permit category or another statutory condition. A well-documented response is more effective than relying on the general proposition that a person has worked or intends to work.
The practical lesson
Administrative decisions must engage with evidence rather than rest on an incomplete account of a worker's history. At the same time, genuine employment and lawful eligibility remain distinct requirements that must both be examined. An annulment of a refusal does not necessarily eliminate the need for further administrative steps.
Source: TAR Lombardia, Milano, Section IV, judgment 16 June 2026, no. 3212, full judgment.
Avv. Fabio Loscerbo
Italian lawyer authorised to practise before the Court of Cassation
Registered in the Italian Chamber of Deputies' Register of Interest Representatives for immigration matters
Registered interest representative in the European Union Transparency Register for migration and asylum, no. 280782895721-36
ORCID: 0009-0004-7030-0428
This article was prepared with the assistance of AI tools, under the author's direction, review and editorial responsibility.
Commenti
Posta un commento